Charitable Reasoning: how the tools of philosophy can help increase belief revision and decrease polarization
TWCF Number
32570
Project Duration
May 1 / 2024
- September 1 / 2026
Core Funding Area
Big Questions
Region
North America
Amount Awarded
$217,283

* A Grant DOI (digital object identifier) is a unique, open, global, persistent and machine-actionable identifier for a grant.

Director
Paul Henne
Institution Lake Forest College

People inevitably disagree on moral, social, and political matters. However, in today’s world, entrenched beliefs are increasingly hindering open, fact-based discussions, leading to heightened polarization and inter-group conflict. A project team led by Paul Henne at Lake Forest College aims to test the efficacy of a strategy designed to encourage even-handed evaluation of counterarguments and increase belief revision in response to sound reasoning. The project will explore two tools of philosophical argumentation as promising interventions:  the principle of charity and the rationalization principle. 

Philosophers have dealt with conflict and disagreement by developing a number of tools to improve the quality of argumentation and debate. When interpreting someone’s arguments, for instance, the charity principle advocates thinking of that person as stating true premises and making good inferences, rather than simply seeking to win the argument. Similarly, the rationalization principle calls for representing a person who holds a belief or set of beliefs that opposes yours as rational (i.e., she has good reasons for her beliefs).

The team will investigate whether putting people in a good epistemic position through the use of these two philosophical tools may improve their evaluation of opposing views, increasing the likelihood of belief revision, and decreasing polarization. 

Disclaimer
Opinions expressed on this page, or any media linked to it, do not necessarily reflect the views of Templeton World Charity Foundation, Inc. Templeton World Charity Foundation, Inc. does not control the content of external links.
Person doing research
Projects &
Resources
Explore the projects we’ve funded. We’ve awarded hundreds of grants to researchers and institutions worldwide.

Projects & Resources